The ugly truth about bridesmaid dresses

Reprinted with permission from the Berthoud Weekly Surveyor

If you could see the entire dress (wedding #2) you'd understand why I was drinking. Photo courtesy of the Susan Richards Historical Society.

The history of the bridal party is a colorful one, with origins in the Anglo-Saxon era when a groom would abduct his bride from a nearby village. He’d enlist help, and this little army of kidnappers evolved into today’s groomsmen. The bride would have her own cadre of friends as well, but if the marriage was completed, they obviously weren’t of much help.

As punishment for the girlfriends’ ineffectiveness, the bride would insist they wear garments so hideous the groomsmen would have to look away, thus ensuring none of them were ever chosen for marriage.

All right, I might have embellished this historical fact just a little, but as a five-time also-ran, er… I mean bridesmaid, I consider myself a bit of an expert on the subject. There are all kinds of anecdotes on the origin of wedding gowns, rings, cake and more, but little has been written about the beleaguered women who assist the bride on her journey to the altar. Maids and matrons of honor and bridesmaids up the wazoo have stoically planned showers, soothed nerves and sup-ported brides throughout the years, only to be rewarded with frocks so bad there are websites dedicated to the phenomenon.

This is why it’s always a good idea for a bride-to-be to choose her closest friends and family to stand attendance at her wedding. Mere acquaintances will have a much harder time keeping a straight face when told that she can wear the dress again, it’s so pretty and practical. When my oldest friend (wedding #5) told me that my tea-length Jessica McClintock dress would definitely be worn again, I smiled and dreamed about all of the garden parties in Birmingham I’d no doubt be invited to.

The corner into which brides back themselves is often the number of bridesmaids chosen. Six or eight women are bound to possess six or eight body types and the most successful fashion designer in the world would be hard-pressed to find the perfect gown for each one. Such was the case with wedding #2 back in the early 1980s. The dress was so bad I didn’t even hide my reaction, but my friend waved me off and explained it was the only one that fit everyone, including her plus-size sisters.

I actually did wear that dress again. And again. The pink dotted-Swiss monstrosity with puffy sleeves and a crinoline-enhanced skirt made an excellent costume as Little Bo Peep, as well as a saloon girl when I volunteered at a mining camp festival for several summers. The first Halloween party was actually hosted by the newly wed couple so the look on her face was worth the cost of the dress.
According to my informal survey, mine wasn’t the only gown ripped out of a scene in “Gone with the Wind.”

“I wore one that was red satin — spectacular in every sense of the word. It had a deep cut back with a big bow at the butt and a princess neckline. I wore it the following Halloween as Scarlett O’Hara,” said a similarly punished bridesmaid.

The cocktail dress with separate floor-length skirt I wore in wedding #1 was the only one of all that I actually did wear again to social events. Sadly, the dress stayed in style longer than that particular marriage.

When considering the legend of the ugly bridesmaid dress, I have to question the bride’s motives. Is it so important to ensure being the center of attention that you’ll cover your best friends with fabric more suited for upholstery or colors not found in nature? One honest soul in my in-formal poll admitted she didn’t make the dress choice too bad, but definitely made sure they didn’t outshine hers.

Maybe it’s time for the soon-to-be-wed women of America to take another look at history. For many years, the attendants’ dresses were much like the bride’s own gown. This tradition was in-tended to confuse evil spirits or jealous suitors that might attempt to harm the newlyweds. Reviving this practice from days of yore would keep the happy couple safe and the bridesmaids happy. Win-win.

As long as I’m taking on tradition, I may as well pick a bone with the wedding industry itself. Is there a plausible reason – besides profit – why the guys can rent their tuxes and the women-in-waiting are required to drop a lot of cash on a dress, shoes and accessories to keep forever? The memories of the inevitable drama that arise when you throw several women and garish floral pat-terns together is enough. Must we also open our closet every day and be reminded of the fittings, the alterations, the expletives? I’m quite positive that we women can take better care of a rental dress than a half dozen overgrown frat boys can. Give us a try and you’ll see a happy, well-dressed bridal party.

This is what happens when hookers get hold of a cotton candy machine. Photo from

In the interest of full disclosure, I am, as of today, always a bridesmaid – never a bride. However, I swear on a stack of Modern Bride magazines never to ask my dearest friend – just one, not six – to wear something I wouldn’t be caught dead in. I also promise not to utter the words “And you can wear it again!” unless I’m hosting a follow-up masquerade reception. Really, I do

5 thoughts on “The ugly truth about bridesmaid dresses

  1. LOL!!! That is a great story. It is sooo true too. I actually did wear two of the four bridesmaids dresses again to other shindigs – one to another wedding 😉 One dress I hated so much that I think I might have given it away the day after the wedding. I had ordered the right size and the tag in the dress was the right size but there was no way on earth the dress was actually the right size. My Mom pulled out every stitch she could to the point my dress did not look like the others but there was nothing we could do. It was horrible. To top it off too I was the tallest, heaviest, blondest, whitest and no pierced ears so I wore flats and no earrings – talk about the bride not standing out LOL!!! I felt like I had a huge arrow over my head that said “look at me” all day long and I do did not want anyone looking at me. I made my wedding easy on my bridesmaids… I didn’t have any… I eloped!

  2. The rental idea was just discussed by a group of bridesmaids I’ll be standing with this summer. The bride was not amused.

    Personally, I think something happens in a brides head, some sort of bridal disorder that occurs the moment the ring goes on her finger. I’d like to say I wasn’t like this, however, I completely lost it on the morning of the wedding when my mom was late picking me and my maid of honor up to get our hair done. I held it together pretty good up until that moment and that moment proved that I too had the disorder.

    It just happens. There’s no cure.

  3. Pingback: Matrimony: The Musical? | Suz's Petals

  4. Pingback: Matrimony: The Musical? | Suz's Petals

  5. Love this. Although I do think the bridesmaids dresses from my first wedding were the best ones ever, I guess we’re all biased when we pick the dress. I’ve been a ‘maid twice, and never worn either dress again. The first one was SO ugly – baby-poop brown, with cap sleeves and a straight skirt – all ten of us looked terrible and mine started falling apart during the reception. I still have it in a trunk somewhere. teh second one we got to pick our dresses in any style as long as they were navy blue… but it’s still in my closet, unworn except that one time.

    By the way, have you seen “27 Dresses”? It’s a rom-com, about an eternal bridesmaid and they make good use of the “The best part is, you can wear it again!” line. 🙂

Whatcha think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s